Its official: The federal government is going to move the train funds out of Wisconsin and Ohio and give them to a plethora of other states, with most of the funds going to New York, California, and Illinois. Wisconsin will be allowed to keep some of the funds to pay for experiences already paid towards the train.
In response, high-speed train manufacturer, Talgo, stated that it would move out of Milwaukee.
Scott Walker called the decision a "victory". Mayor Barrett looked visibly upset during a press conference, stating that California's workers got an early "Christmas President".
Train opponents are largely framing the decision as a "victory" for the state of Wisconsin. Sticking with their theme of definition, Walker and other opponents are arguing that Wisconsinites were able to overturn a decision by the Federal government to stop a train that they never wanted and could not pay for.
Proponents are labeling the victory a "tragedy" for Wisconsin workers. The focus has been jobs--proponents have discussed the number of jobs that Wisconsin will lose as a result of the decision. This includes Talgo jobs, construction jobs, and long-term operating jobs. Some, like Barrett, have taken a sarcastic tone, by stating that other states should "thank" Walker for the influx of jobs that Wisconsin's rail money will bring to their states. Barrett even argued that CA should name their rail line the "Badger Line".
Talgo's response focused on a combination of jobs and modern technology. A spokesperson for Talgo discussed the loss of jobs, but also discussed how Wisconsin would miss out on new, modern technology that will be the shape of transportation in the future.
Throughout the debate, rail opponents have stayed with the same theme. Their initial argument that public transportation is a luxury was able to translate well to the high speed rail. They were able to successfully use the definition of "luxury" to shift to a definition of "choice"--they were able to argue that public transportation is a luxury that we cannot afford in this economy, and the federal government should not be able to "force" Wisconsin to build public transportation--Wisconsinites should have a "choice" in the matter.
This is in contrast to proponent's response to the train, whose rhetorical strategies seemed to change more often. There was not a clear "theme" to the proponents side that stayed throughout the debate. Initially arguing that the train was a "good" way to create jobs and connect people to jobs in a bad economy, proponents shifted their argument to an argument of waste. Trying to combat opponents' claim that Wisconsin cannot afford an "$80 million dollar" train, they began to argue that we cannot afford to stop it. They discussed the amount of money that was already spent on the Train and Talgo, as well as the number of jobs that were lost. They argued that is money would be "wasted" if the train was stopped in Wisconsin. However, they never quite had an easy, memorable figure like the opponent's "$80 million" that they were able to successfully repeat throughout the controversy.
It seems as though the train decision came at the perfect time--just as the semester is coming to a close. However, the debate over public transportation is not over. The Milwaukee County Transit System, the Hiawatha line from Milwaukee to Chicago, and the Proposed KRM commuter line from Milwaukee to Kenosha are just some examples of public transportation projects that continue to be controversial throughout Southeast Wisconsin. It will be interesting to see if, and how, the train controversy will impact the arguments for and against these projects.
Saturday, December 11, 2010
Thursday, December 9, 2010
Feds Make A Decision on Train
Well, it appears as though there has finally been a decision about the proposed high-speed rail from Milwaukee to Madison. While it is not "official", it is reported that the Department of Transportaion will make an announcement today or tomorrow, stating that it is pulling the train funding from Ohio and Wisconsin and sending it to New York, California, and Illinois to build rails in those states. I will have more information when the annoucement happens!
http://www.jsonline.com/news/statepolitics/111602539.html
http://www.jsonline.com/news/statepolitics/111602539.html
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)