Saturday, December 11, 2010

Train Decision

Its official: The federal government is going to move the train funds out of Wisconsin and Ohio and give them to a plethora of other states, with most of the funds going to New York, California, and Illinois. Wisconsin will be allowed to keep some of the funds to pay for experiences already paid towards the train.

In response, high-speed train manufacturer, Talgo, stated that it would move out of Milwaukee.

Scott Walker called the decision a "victory". Mayor Barrett looked visibly upset during a press conference, stating that California's workers got an early "Christmas President".

Train opponents are largely framing the decision as a "victory" for the state of Wisconsin. Sticking with their theme of definition, Walker and other opponents are arguing that Wisconsinites were able to overturn a decision by the Federal government to stop a train that they never wanted and could not pay for.

Proponents are labeling the victory a "tragedy" for Wisconsin workers. The focus has been jobs--proponents have discussed the number of jobs that Wisconsin will lose as a result of the decision. This includes Talgo jobs, construction jobs, and long-term operating jobs. Some, like Barrett, have taken a sarcastic tone, by stating that other states should "thank" Walker for the influx of jobs that Wisconsin's rail money will bring  to their states. Barrett even argued that CA should name their rail line the "Badger Line".

Talgo's response focused on a combination of jobs and modern technology. A spokesperson for Talgo discussed the loss of jobs, but also discussed how Wisconsin would miss out on new, modern technology that will be the shape of transportation in the future.

Throughout the debate, rail opponents have stayed with the same theme. Their initial argument that public transportation is a luxury was able to translate well to the high speed rail. They were able to successfully use the definition of "luxury" to shift to a definition of "choice"--they were able to argue that public transportation is a luxury that we cannot afford in this economy, and the federal government should not be able to "force" Wisconsin to build public transportation--Wisconsinites should have a "choice" in the matter.

This is in contrast to proponent's response to the train, whose rhetorical strategies seemed to change more often. There was not a clear "theme" to the proponents side that stayed throughout the debate. Initially arguing that the train was a "good" way to create jobs and connect people to jobs in a bad economy, proponents shifted their argument to an argument of waste. Trying to combat opponents' claim that Wisconsin cannot afford an "$80 million dollar" train, they began to argue that we cannot afford to stop it. They discussed the amount of money that was already spent on the Train and Talgo, as well as the number of jobs that were lost. They argued that is money would be "wasted" if the train was stopped in Wisconsin. However, they never quite had an easy, memorable figure like the opponent's "$80 million" that they were able to successfully repeat throughout the controversy. 

It seems as though the train decision came at the perfect time--just as the semester is coming to a close. However, the debate over public transportation is not over. The Milwaukee County Transit System, the Hiawatha line from Milwaukee to Chicago,  and the Proposed KRM commuter line from Milwaukee to Kenosha are just some examples of public transportation projects that continue to be controversial throughout Southeast Wisconsin. It will be interesting to see if, and how, the train controversy will impact the arguments for and against these projects.

Thursday, December 9, 2010

Feds Make A Decision on Train

Well, it appears as though there has finally been a decision about the proposed high-speed rail from Milwaukee to Madison. While it is not "official", it is reported that the Department of Transportaion will make an announcement today or tomorrow, stating that it is pulling the train funding from Ohio and Wisconsin and sending it to New York, California, and Illinois to build rails in those states. I will have more information when the annoucement happens!

http://www.jsonline.com/news/statepolitics/111602539.html

Monday, November 22, 2010

I support the train, just not THAT train..

In a new twist to the train saga in Wisconsin, Scott Walker has stated that he would be willing to spend the federal money on a train project...just not the proposed high speed rail from Milwaukee to Madison. Instead, he stated that he would be willing to use the money to help fund the current Amtrak Hiawatha line from Milwaukee to Chicago. While dedicating the funds to roads would still be Walker's first priority, he supported the Hiawatha line during his campaign, and would like to use the money to re-vamp the line.
http://www.jsonline.com/news/statepolitics/108232259.html

This is an interesting development, because it is the first time that Walker has stated he would be willing to use the funds for a rail. It appears as though it may be an argument of dissociation. Walker is trying to highlight a difference between rails. He is trying to argue that that Hiawatha rail is good, while the Milwaukee to Madison train is bad or unnecessary or too expensive. It it almost as if he is creating a separation between "real" trains and "proposed/apparent" trains. The Hiawatha train already exists and is popular and efficient. By contrast, the train from Milwaukee to Madison is only hypothetical, and Walker argues that the benefits are not worth the costs. He is trying to distinguish between different types of  trains.

In other news, La Hood has stated that North Carolina may be the state to receive the train funds if Wisconsin says no.

As stated earlier, the federal government has stated that a change in how the proposed train money is spent would require a vote in Congress. Wisconsin Republicans in DC intend to do just that. All 3 Republican members of the house from Wisconsin introduced a bill that would allow Wisconsin and other states to return the train money, and  to use that money to reduce the deficit, rather than having the funds go to other pro-train states.
http://www.jsonline.com/news/statepolitics/108470944.html

Wednesday, November 17, 2010

It's the Economy, Stupid

Given the hard economic times, both proponents and opponents of transit (particularly the train from Milwaukee to Madison), have tried to associate their arguments with job creation.

As stated before, opponents have argued that the train is a waste of taxpayer dollars. They argue that the tax money that would be needed to operate the train would be a harmful way to spend money in the economy. They state that Wisconsin's taxes have made it hard for businesses to stay in Wisconsin, and prevented new businesses from moving to Wisconsin. Thus, adding taxes for a "luxury" service would only hurt Wisconsin's business climate.

As far as responding to the argument that the train will connect people to jobs, transit opponents state that this is simply not factual.  On "Sunday Insight" with Charlie Sykes, which airs in Milwaukee every Sunday morning, Sykes argues that the people who would supposedly ride the train also own cars (Sunday, Nov. 14th). Therefore, the train would not help any different individuals connect to jobs in Madison or Milwaukee. Instead, it is a luxury item that would allow current commuters to choose between using their cars or riding the train. This was a central argument in Walker's election. Lieutenant-Governor Elect Rebecca Kleefisch used this argument in her primary campaign ad, when she stated that "I know that I do not need an $800 million dollar high speed train to get me to work in Madison. I'm a Mom, and I have a mini-van".
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=it0V5HFalZA

Proponents also associate their position with job creation, stating that the train will help jobs. Currently, they have responded to Walker's stance that federal funding should not go towards building a train in Milwaukee. They argue that stopping the train will automatically destroy jobs in Wisconsin. Gov. Quinn of Illinois wrote a letter to Talgo, the company that was supposed to create the high-speed trains for the rail, inviting the company to move from Milwaukee to Illinois. According to Talgo, the company is considering the move:
"If Wisconsin is losing its enthusiasm for its rail program and others are not, we could go to Illinois and manufacture world-class trains there," said Nora Friend, Talgo vice president for public affairs and business development. "We certainly appreciate Gov. Quinn reaching out to us. We will consider very seriously states that want to grow their rail program."
 http://www.jsonline.com/news/wisconsin/107071258.html
Proponents argue that this will eliminate hundreds of jobs in Milwaukee, including 250 Talgo jobs and the proposed construction jobs that would be created to help build the train. They also continue to argue that the train, like any form of public transportation, does link individuals to jobs. They argue that train riders will include those with cars and those without them, and will be fundamental to help link employees to employers throughout the state.

The city of Milwaukee has also argued that shutting down the train will be a waste of taxpayer dollars. The city of Milwaukee has reportedly already spent millions of dollars to renovate the old Tower building for Talgo, and may sue the the state for that money if the state does not move forward with the initial train plans.

Both proponents and opponents are trying to use association to link their positions with job creation in this tough economy. It appears as though this is a battle that is not going away any time soon, and new players (such as Illinois) continue to influence the transit debate! I will continue to try to keep this blog updated with all the new events and arguments.

Tuesday, November 16, 2010

Community

Proponents of the train have also tried to argue that the proposed train will be part of a larger rail project that will eventually connect cities across the United States. Although the train in Wisconsin is only being funded currently to run from Milwaukee to Madison, the long-term vision includes the train moving down to Chicago, and extending further up north to other cities in Wisconsin, and possibly west to Minneapolis. 

Proponents argue that if Wisconsin turns down the opportunity to bring a train to its state, Wisconsin could be left out of the overall plans. Many argue that it would not be hard to have a rail  that runs from Chicago to Minneapolis with the cooperation of Iowa and other states. In other words, the plan for a rail that connects across the Midwest, and eventually the U.S., could move forward by completely bypassing the state of Wisconsin. If Wisconsin does not want to be a part of the rail project, it could lose out on tourism and business opportunities. Proponents argue that the rail would bring 'states together' and Wisconsin would be left out of that community. Wisconsin would be 'left out' of the 'opportunity' to take place in a national project that focuses on connecting people.

Obama V. Walker

Since Walker's letter to Secretary of Transportation La Hood, the federal government has responded.

The federal government is using an argument of Transcendence. They are arguing that their plan for a high-speed rail in Wisconsin is just part of a larger investment in high-speed rails across the country. The train is Wisconsin is just one small step in the dream to eventually have a larger rail system that connects the United States.

The federal government has responded to Walker's argument about choice, by stating that Wisconsin does have a choice: They can choose to build the train or send the money back. If that happens, the funding would likely go to other states who want to build high speed rails. Already, New York and Illinois have come forward requesting the funding to build high-speed rails in their own states if states like Ohio and Wisconsin turn it down.As La Hood states, the federal government does not have the power to force Wisconsin to build the train if the state government does not want to.

The federal government continues their argument of quality: that a nation-wide rail system is valuable to the nation. Because they believe in its value, they will not allow the money to be used for other projects that do not support their overall vision. They argue that it was not just the Obama administration that supported the idea of the trains,but that the trains were approved by both the U.S. House of Represenatives and the U.S. Senate. Thus, the "people" do suppor the train, and any changes to the proposed funding would also have to come from the people: if the funds were to go to Wisconsin's roads, it woud require a vote in Congress.

Monday, November 15, 2010

Walker V. Obama

Since I last posted, the results of the midterm election are in. The debate over public transportation, specifically the high-speed rail from Milwaukee to Madison, has taken center stage since the election of Governor-elect Walker.

Governor-elect Walker is sticking to his campaign promise that he will guarantee that the proposed train does not move forward in Wisconsin. His argument has not changed since pre-election: that Wisconsinites have not had a 'choice' in decided whether or not they wanted the train. He argues that Wisconsinites do not want the train, and Wisconsin should be allowed to allocate the funds to other projects, including improving roads. Walker's election as Governor has added another element to his argument, because Walker cites that his election was a mandate on the train. He argues that one of the reasons that voters put him into office is because they also do not support the train:
"All across the country, in states like Wisconsin, Ohio and Florida, the voters chose new governors who are opposed to diverting transportation funding to passenger rail. I believe it would be unwise for the Obama administration to ignore the will of the voters,"

Like the quote above highlights, Walker also uses the election of anti-rail governors in other states as a multi-state mandate against the federal government's proposed train system.

Walker is not just focused on stopping the train, but tries to amplify the problems with the current roads and bridges in Wisconsin. He argues that our current infrastructure is "literally crumbling". He makes a contrast between how the federal government (as outsiders) want to spend the money and how the people of Wisconsin want to spend the money. By discussing the problems with Wisconsin's roads and bridges, Walker tries to demonstrate that the federal government is not only out of touch with what Wisconsinites want, but the type of transportation projects that Wisconsin needs.

http://www.jsonline.com/news/statepolitics/106966203.html