Given the hard economic times, both proponents and opponents of transit (particularly the train from Milwaukee to Madison), have tried to associate their arguments with job creation.
As stated before, opponents have argued that the train is a waste of taxpayer dollars. They argue that the tax money that would be needed to operate the train would be a harmful way to spend money in the economy. They state that Wisconsin's taxes have made it hard for businesses to stay in Wisconsin, and prevented new businesses from moving to Wisconsin. Thus, adding taxes for a "luxury" service would only hurt Wisconsin's business climate.
As far as responding to the argument that the train will connect people to jobs, transit opponents state that this is simply not factual. On "Sunday Insight" with Charlie Sykes, which airs in Milwaukee every Sunday morning, Sykes argues that the people who would supposedly ride the train also own cars (Sunday, Nov. 14th). Therefore, the train would not help any different individuals connect to jobs in Madison or Milwaukee. Instead, it is a luxury item that would allow current commuters to choose between using their cars or riding the train. This was a central argument in Walker's election. Lieutenant-Governor Elect Rebecca Kleefisch used this argument in her primary campaign ad, when she stated that "I know that I do not need an $800 million dollar high speed train to get me to work in Madison. I'm a Mom, and I have a mini-van".
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=it0V5HFalZA
Proponents also associate their position with job creation, stating that the train will help jobs. Currently, they have responded to Walker's stance that federal funding should not go towards building a train in Milwaukee. They argue that stopping the train will automatically destroy jobs in Wisconsin. Gov. Quinn of Illinois wrote a letter to Talgo, the company that was supposed to create the high-speed trains for the rail, inviting the company to move from Milwaukee to Illinois. According to Talgo, the company is considering the move:
"If Wisconsin is losing its enthusiasm for its rail program and others are not, we could go to Illinois and manufacture world-class trains there," said Nora Friend, Talgo vice president for public affairs and business development. "We certainly appreciate Gov. Quinn reaching out to us. We will consider very seriously states that want to grow their rail program."
http://www.jsonline.com/news/wisconsin/107071258.html
Proponents argue that this will eliminate hundreds of jobs in Milwaukee, including 250 Talgo jobs and the proposed construction jobs that would be created to help build the train. They also continue to argue that the train, like any form of public transportation, does link individuals to jobs. They argue that train riders will include those with cars and those without them, and will be fundamental to help link employees to employers throughout the state.
The city of Milwaukee has also argued that shutting down the train will be a waste of taxpayer dollars. The city of Milwaukee has reportedly already spent millions of dollars to renovate the old Tower building for Talgo, and may sue the the state for that money if the state does not move forward with the initial train plans.
Both proponents and opponents are trying to use association to link their positions with job creation in this tough economy. It appears as though this is a battle that is not going away any time soon, and new players (such as Illinois) continue to influence the transit debate! I will continue to try to keep this blog updated with all the new events and arguments.
How have opponents of the rail responded to the "waste argument" from Milwaukee? From our discussion in class, it seemed as though arguments about waste were not very persuasive, and I'm wondering if the opponents have engaged this argument directly or answered it with silence.
ReplyDeleteAlso, if the Talgo company does pull out and move to Illinois, are there any predictions on how much money that will cost the state?
It is really hard to pin down how much it will costs. Gov. Doyle recently stated it would cost the state $100 million. The details are in this article:
ReplyDeletehttp://www.jsonline.com/news/wisconsin/106914208.html
So far, I have not seen a response to this argument from opponents. Good observation! It will be interesting to see how the waste argument plays out.
This comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteSorry about the deleted comment...I wanted to edit after posting and it would only let me delete...so what follows is essentially the same as my earlier comment.
ReplyDeleteA really interesting case-study. A friend of mine in the Geography department is interested in this issuse as well and his entry point for analysis is the hegemonic role of the automobile in American culture.
Do you get a sense for the same when you examine the anti-rail discourse?
I am just curious as they look at talgo, why was the project not run through racine rail, or any of the other existing companies that build rail systems in the great milwaukee area? I am sure they specialize in high speed, but i just wonder if the others were given coonsideration for the contracts.
ReplyDelete