Sunday, October 24, 2010

Analogy

The last time I posted, I discussed Walker's use of definition in his opposition to the high speed rail.
I decided to post today on how Barrett, the Democratic candidate for governor in Wisconsin, has articulated his support for the high speed rail.
He has responded to Walker's 'choice' criticism by using the strategy of analogy and definition.
Walker and other train opponents discuss the train as an expensive proposal that has been 'forced' upon Wisconsinites against their will. By contrast, Barrett defines the proposed train as an investment that the federal government has made to help the people of Wisconsin. He acknowledges that the state may have to fund some of the day to day operating costs, but argues that those cost are minor compared to the overall investment. To make his argument stronger, he compares the investment in high speed rail to Eisenhower's investment in the interstate system:
"Are there going to be ongoing operational costs? Yeah, there are. But I'm just glad these guys weren't around when Eisenhower was putting together the interstate system because the federal government doesn't pay for snow plowing on the interstate system.".
Barrett is careful to link the rail to another federal investment that most Americans rely on, the interstate system. Like the interstate system, there are still operating costs that states must pay (ie: snow plowing), but those appear as a necessary and minor part of the overall federal investment. By using analogy to compare the interstate to the high speed rail, Barrett is able to frame the rail as an important and vital investment that we do not want to give up due to the relatively small operational cost to the state.

Barrett also uses definition to counter Walker's claim that Wisconsinites did not have the opportunity to 'vote on' or choose the high speed rail. Walker argues that the federal government has taken away Wisconsin's 'choice' . Barrett argues that Wisconsin does have a choice in the rail--the choice to keep the money, or send it elsewhere:
"(Walker) can say no, and he says he's going to say no. And the big winner in that will probably be Florida because Florida is receiving $2.2 billion, but their system costs $3.7 billion. So this would fit in very nicely in to finish Florida's system. He's not running for governor of Florida, but he'll make a lot of people in Florida really, really, really happy with his position. I don't want to give those $800 million away to another state."

To Barrett, Wisconsinites can choose to let the federal government invest in Wisconsin's transportation system, or choose to deny the funds and give Florida the opportunity instead.  To Barrett, the choice lies in whether Wisconsin wants to embrace the investment, or give it away to other states.

No comments:

Post a Comment