Monday, October 4, 2010

Stasis

 Perhaps one of the challenges in the transit debate is that proponents and opponents are not arguing on the same level.

First, I am not trying to suggest that the debate over transit can be reduced to two simple ‘sides’ of opponents and proponents. The debate is very complicated, with fractions on both sides and even arguments that fit in between. However, it is interesting to examine where the dominant debates currently stand.

Those who argue in favor of transit discuss public transportation as a, good, positive part of the community. They argue that transit is ‘good’ for a community because it links individuals to jobs, consumers to businesses, gives low-income  and disabled individuals an avenue to get around the city (make appointments, go grocery shopping, get to work), and is a green alternative to driving. This is by no means an exhaustive list, but showcases just some of the ways that transit advocates have argued that transit is ‘good’ for a community. This type of argument makes an evaluation of transit. It states that transit is ‘good’ and funding public transportation is ‘right’ because it gives all community members access to transportation.

Those who oppose the funding of public transportation are arguing on a different level. They do not make claims about whether public transportation is inherently ‘good’ or ‘bad’. Instead, they are focused on defining just what public transportation is. To opponents, public transportation is a ‘luxury’. They see it not as a necessity, but a luxury to those cities and individuals that can afford it. If a municipality is facing tough economic challenges—as both our city and county are currently—it only makes sense to cut out luxury services and continue to fund the necessary ones. They are arguing on the basis of defining what transit is, rather than making an evaluative statement about it being ‘good’ or ‘bad’.

In many ways, this has frozen the debate because the parties are not arguing on the same level. The proponents are trying to argue that transit is ‘good’, but the opponents are not responding by saying that is it is ‘bad’. Instead, they are arguing about how we define transit. Proponents are not trying to define transit, but argue its value. Because they are not arguing on the same plane, an almost ‘stalemate’ has occurred.  

1 comment:

  1. I don't get how public transportation can be a luxury. People use it to get to work, to school, to the grocery store, and so on. Cars really are the luxury, the luxury of well-off to be able to go where they want to when they want to.

    Perhaps a redefinition of luxury is occurring as a way to find ways to justify budget cuts. And, as people are not very motivated to get out there, maybe it's just the easiest issue.

    Why don't proponents of public transportation argue that the real (as opposed to apparent) luxury is cars and we should be focusing on the necessity of public transit?

    ReplyDelete