Tuesday, November 16, 2010

Obama V. Walker

Since Walker's letter to Secretary of Transportation La Hood, the federal government has responded.

The federal government is using an argument of Transcendence. They are arguing that their plan for a high-speed rail in Wisconsin is just part of a larger investment in high-speed rails across the country. The train is Wisconsin is just one small step in the dream to eventually have a larger rail system that connects the United States.

The federal government has responded to Walker's argument about choice, by stating that Wisconsin does have a choice: They can choose to build the train or send the money back. If that happens, the funding would likely go to other states who want to build high speed rails. Already, New York and Illinois have come forward requesting the funding to build high-speed rails in their own states if states like Ohio and Wisconsin turn it down.As La Hood states, the federal government does not have the power to force Wisconsin to build the train if the state government does not want to.

The federal government continues their argument of quality: that a nation-wide rail system is valuable to the nation. Because they believe in its value, they will not allow the money to be used for other projects that do not support their overall vision. They argue that it was not just the Obama administration that supported the idea of the trains,but that the trains were approved by both the U.S. House of Represenatives and the U.S. Senate. Thus, the "people" do suppor the train, and any changes to the proposed funding would also have to come from the people: if the funds were to go to Wisconsin's roads, it woud require a vote in Congress.

4 comments:

  1. Really interesting development: has the Walker administration responded? I think that this complicates the whole economic argument. If Wisconsin needs to send back the money allocated for the train, does that also include the money already spent (i.e. in Milwaukee for the Talgo company)? If so, then it seems that not building the train would be a devastating economic blow.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Yes..it seems as though the new debate is centered around which solution would costs more (keeping the train or stopping the train). The city has stated that it has spent millions of dollars on Talgo, and may sue the state if it does not move forward with the train.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Wow, you really do have a good debate here. Have you seen any arguments that employ the "we have already started, so can't turn back now" position? (I can't remember the term for that off the top of my head...

    ReplyDelete
  4. Yes I have seen this...I will try to find some texts to reflect this. Good point/idea!

    ReplyDelete